Coco Man: a Review

What’s the book? Coco Man by Laken Hyson Schmalz

What kind of dark is it? It’s a romantic thriller with hints of the supernatural but not a very dark one

How good is it? 1/10 red flags

If I’m remembering right, I got this book from the ‘local authors’ shelf at Maria’s Bookshop in Durango, Colorado. It seems to be self-published and I’m guessing all the editors and proofreaders are the author’s friends and family. I’m betting they’re all incredibly nice people; Schmalz doesn’t have even one friend brutally honest enough to tell her she’s using ‘exacerbated’ wrong, or that ‘shudder’ and ‘shutter’ are not the same word. Not one person was honest enough to tell her to tighten up her prose and it shows. If you’ve ever had to write a two-page essay with only one page worth of actual information, you’ll know how this entire book feels. On the most basic, sentence-by-sentence level, it feels like a laboriously padded high school assignment. It hurt to read.

I picked the book up because I like trying obscure local things even when they’re not very good. I admire the effort. This one promised to be part romance, part thriller, with folkloric elements that sounded intriguing. It turned out to be about five percent thriller and haunting, ninety-five percent romance. Not steamy smutty romance, though. This is torturous and tame. We follow Palmer Lane as she meets her first love, Callum, in high school. We watch them have awkward sex in high school. We watch them go off to college, where Callum parties hard, drops out, and makes enough dumb decisions that Palmer sensibly dumps his drug-addled ass. She misses him terribly for months and when she breaks down and calls him, he doesn’t come running fast enough and she screams at him and sends him away again. All this normal-seeming college drama breaks Palmer’s heart enough that she’s sure she’ll never be able to love again.

So instead of looking for love, Palmer sets out to solve the disappearance of her great-aunt. She meets Doctor Hartman Roth, a hot rich oral surgeon, as she searches for her great-aunt’s dental records. Hartman slowly breaks down Palmer’s impenetrable walls with his compassion and gentleness. He’s almost inhumanly perfect. Is he too perfect?

All this romance is framed by a mysterious assault that’s left Palmer with amnesia. We follow both romances as her memory slowly returns in conveniently chronological order. Interspersed throughout the story are also haunted moments where Palmer feels like she’s being followed by an otherworldly being, sometimes catching glimpses out of the corner of her eye or seeing horrifying visions and nightmares. Callum didn’t believe her when she took the risk of telling him about her supernatural experiences but Hartman, of course, has been nothing but supportive.

There’s a twist ending. I won’t tell you what it is but I probably don’t need to. I bet you can guess.

It’s not the worst plot ever. In fact, it’s fine for an amateur first effort. By the end of the book I could not stop rolling my eyes and wishing for a swift end but now, with a little distance, I can see it’s not as mind-numbingly awful as it felt at the time. It’s really the god-awful prose and the flat boring characters that bring it down. If Ms. Schmalz goes on to write more books, she needs to find meaner people to help her punch them up and bring them to life. Way meaner people. Way meaner.

Leave a Reply