What’s the book? Maigret’s Revolver by Georges Simenon
What kind of dark is it? a very mild murder mystery
How good is it? 2/10 stolen guns

I got this the way I get most of my old pulpy mysteries, at a used bookstore. I’d never heard of Simenon but he seemed famous and pulpy so I took a chance. The woman who rang me up gushed a bit about him, so that was encouraging. I later looked up Georges Simenon and he seems like the king of French mysteries. He wrote tons of books, both pulp mysteries and more serious stuff. His Maigret mysteries are praised for their compassionate psychological approach to crime novels and for capturing the vibe of mid-century Paris.
Chief Inspector Maigret is very calm, very collected, unfazed by anything. He barely breaks a sweat as he solves this mystery. He’s a famous police officer but this one is personal. A young man who came to his home looking for him and it seems he stole Maigret’s revolver while he was there. It’s not Maigret’s police gun, it’s an American souvenir, given to him for solving a mystery on a visit there. (Because of course his parting gift from the FBI is a pistol.)
This isn’t an official case but as Maigret calls around looking for this gun thief he runs across a murder that might be connected. Maigret becomes convinced that the young man wanted to talk about this very murder; not finding Maigret, the young man may have stolen the gun intending to take matters into his own hands.
Maigret spends a lot of time on the phone yelling ‘what?’ because phone service in mid-century Paris is awful, interviewing unpleasant French people (including several jaded Parisian women he does not flirt with because he’s happily married), and taking a quiet trip to England as he follows the thief. When he find the thief, instead of action we get Maigret talking sense into the young man before he can do something truly awful. It’s all kind of prim and boring, if I’m being honest. I don’t expect every mystery to be Mike Hammer punching random dudes in the face and turning lesbians straight but I wanted a little more action than this. Some twists and turns, surprising insights, a little danger, but this book had not much of anything I read mysteries for. It’s so understated and calm, the story faded as soon as I read it.
I’ve only read the one Maigret mystery so I certainly can’t judge the whole series but so far I don’t see the appeal. It’s a little too tame and subtle for me. Maybe I just got a dud and should try a more famous Maigret mystery. Maybe I should look up a TV adaptation on BritBox or PBS Masterpiece. Maybe I should go back to Mickey Spillane or Agatha Christie. But maybe Maigret is the perfect detective for you. If you want a cozy read where the famous detective saves a wayward youth from his own anger, this is the mystery for you.